Critical Habitat Designations Extend Government Overreach

Late last week, I joined my colleagues from Arkansas’ Congressional delegation in writing a letter to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) urging it to not expand its critical habitat designations for two target species, the Neosho Mucket and the Rabbitsfoot Mussel.

While we, as Arkansans, must always do our best to protect the wildlife and natural resources of this great state, the FWS’ critical habitat designation extended well beyond reasonable protection for these species. For example, the proposal extended more than 750 river miles, potentially impacting more than 40 percent of Arkansas’ surface area. In addition, 90 percent of the rivers and streams included in the designation passed through private property, which could leave productive land fallow.

After we received the proposal, my colleagues and I noticed several issues that could create serious headaches and economic hardships for Arkansans. First, the proposed designations covered areas where the species don’t reside or can even exist. Furthermore, the FWS didn’t provide any scientific basis for the inclusion of these lands. Secondly, the FWS made no mention how it would regulate water pollution into these critical habitat designations, including regulations for citizens holding National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permits. Thirdly, the FWS didn’t examine whether voluntary conservation efforts would disappear as landowners pay more money to come under compliance. Lastly, the FWS did a poor job conducting an economic analysis on how these designations would impact Arkansas. The Obama Administration proposed a rule in 2012 severely limiting the type of economic analysis required for a critical habitat designation. Because of these limits, the FWS likely never considered how the designation would impact road and bridge improvements, agriculture, forestry, grazing activities, recreational uses, water and wastewater treatments, and energy development.

Looking particularly at the Rabbitsfoot Mussel, the FWS extended its designation well beyond Arkansas, incorporating 13 other states. Yet, the Agency unfairly targeted our state, loading about half of the species’ critical habitat within our borders.

Put simply, the Agency’s original designation was too big without a scientific basis for its reach, and it would place an economic strain on areas already facing burdensome regulations.

Because of your comments—both to the FWS and your Arkansas delegation—the Agency notified us it would reduce the scope of these critical habitat designations, making a final decision sometime during March.

As your representative, I will monitor the Agency’s progress toward this decision and seek input throughout Arkansas’ First District on how a designation impacts our communities. I urge you to voice your concerns before the March deadline.

Recent Posts

Jun 14, 2024
Veterans' Affairs

Arkansas House Delegation to McDonough: The Politicization of the VA is Inappropriate

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Contact: Sara Robertson, Crawford Brooke Nethercott, Hill Sarah Henderson, Westerman Olivia Tripodi, Womack Arkansas House Delegation to McDonough: The Politicization of the VA is Inappropriate 6/14/2024 Washington, D.C. — Congressmen Rick Crawford (AR-01), French Hill (AR-02), Steve Womack (AR-03), and Bruce Westerman (AR-04) sent a letter to U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Secretary Denis […]

May 29, 2024

Arkansas Delegation Supports Governor’s Request for Major Disaster Declaration

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Contact: Boozman, Sara Lasure or Matthew Wester Cotton, Caroline Tabler or Patrick McCann Crawford, Sara Robertson Hill, Brooke Nethercott Womack, Olivia Tripodi Westerman, Sarah Henderson Arkansas Delegation Supports Governor’s Request for Major Disaster Declaration 5/29/2024 Washington, D.C. — U.S. Senators John Boozman and Tom Cotton—along with Congressmen Steve Womack, Rick Crawford, French Hill and Bruce Westerman—wrote to President Joe Biden urging him to […]

Rep. Crawford Introduces EOD Legislation

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASEContact: Sara Robertson ( Rep. Crawford Introduces EOD Legislation 5/22/2024 Washington, D.C. – Congressman Rick Crawford (AR-01) introduced a series of bills this week that will improve the welfare of our military’s Explosive Ordnance Disposal (EOD) personnel. Crawford, the founder and chairman of the House EOD Caucus, worked with caucus members on the House […]