Well-Intentioned House Budget Lacks Permanent Enforcement

Apr 11, 2014
Weekly Column Achieves

The U.S. House of Representatives passed its Fiscal Year 2015 budget April 10 by a vote of 219 to 205. The new budget slashes $5.1 trillion in federal government spending over the next 10 years and maintains tax breaks for struggling small businesses trying to create jobs.

Considering our nation is currently straddled with more than $17.5 trillion in debt, any attempt to rein in wasteful spending should come as a welcome relief.

I definitely applaud the efforts of my House colleagues to fix this growing burden, but I also believe they glossed over our country’s glaring issue. Without permanent spending controls in Washington, any new budget reducing spending only applies a small bandage to a gaping wound.

My first thought upon seeing this budget — which goes back to last year and previous budgets — is that there is no underlying mechanism to enforce it. The budget is still just a non-binding resolution that doesn’t have the enforcement of permanent spending controls, such as a Spending Limitation Amendment (SLA) or a Balanced Budget Amendment (BBA). Consequently, I made the decision a while back to not support these budgets, because they can’t be enforced.

The last three decades of wasteful government spending give us a pretty clear indication that non-binding budget resolutions cannot give our country a balanced budget. Setting a new budget is a futile task absent permanent spending controls that require Congress to set priorities and then actually stick with the plan; which cannot happen with a simple, non-binding resolution.

Permanent spending controls are the only mechanism we have to enforce an otherwise statutory budget resolution that has no binding authority. I mean, the next Congress — which can look completely different every two years — often doesn’t follow the direction set by the previous one, unless a Constitutional Amendment requires it to do so.

It’s similar to taking a new job. New employees don’t do everything the same way their predecessors did. They certainly incorporate some of the same ideas and techniques, but they will always do their job differently compared with the previous hires.

However, employers can set ground rules for important job duties. These lay out specific work requirements and the mandatory results from each employee. So, while employee faces may change, these don’t.

We need Congress to have the same, enforceable ground rules preventing our country from heading further into debt.

The biggest complaint I hear regarding a SLA or a BBA is that it just won’t happen. I don’t consider passing such legislation an easy battle, but it’s a task Congress must undertake to prove to the American people it will spend taxpayers’ hard-earned money wisely.

Until then, we can expect to see this same problem with different results.

Recent Posts


Jul 1, 2024
Press

Rep. Crawford Statement on SCOTUS Decision in Trump v. United States

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Contact: Sara Robertson (Sara.Robertson2@mail.house.gov) Rep. Crawford Statement on SCOTUS Decision in Trump v. United States 7/1/2024 Washington, D.C. — Representative Rick Crawford (AR-01) released the following statement after the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Trump v. United States. “The SCOTUS decision today confirms that a President is immune from criminal prosecution for official acts within his […]



Jun 27, 2024
Economy

Steel Caucus Voices Concerns of Potential Trade Status Change for Vietnam

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Contact: Sara Robertson (Sara.Robertson2@mail.house.gov) Steel Caucus Voices Concerns of Potential Trade Status Change for Vietnam 6/27/2024 Washington, D.C. – 37 Bipartisan Members of the Congressional Steel Caucus, led by Chairman Rick Crawford (AR-01) and Vice Chairman Frank Mrvan (IN-01) sent a letter to the secretary of commerce, Gina Raimondo, expressing concern about the department’s reconsideration […]



Jun 18, 2024
Immigration

Rep. Crawford’s Statement on Biden’s Mass Amnesty Order

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Contact: Sara Robertson (Sara.Robertson2@mail.house.gov) Rep. Crawford’s Statement on Biden’s Mass Amnesty Order 6/18/2024 Washington, D.C. — Representative Rick Crawford (AR-01) released the following statement regarding President Biden’s plan to grant amnesty to hundreds of thousands of illegal immigrants.  “With illegal immigration soaring under President Biden’s open-border policies, straining law enforcement, public services, and resulting in […]